Hollywood's take on "conflict diamonds" has brought attention back in
a big way to how gems associated with wealth and glamour have too often meant
war and suffering in Africa.
The film Blood Diamond, which opened
on Friday in US theaters, is set in late 1990s Sierra Leone, when the West
African country was in the throes of a civil war in which untraceable diamonds
allegedly funded fighters who hacked off people's hands with machetes and burned
entire villages.
Since then, the situation has improved dramatically. But while diamonds may
no longer be fueling war, they are a long way from helping pull people out of
poverty on a continent that produces about 65 percent of the world's diamonds,
valued at about US$8.4 billion a year, the World Diamond Council says.
Wars in Sierra Leone, Liberia, Angola and the Democratic Republic of the
Congo (DRC) have given way to peace deals -- and even to democratic elections.
Congo inaugurated its first freely elected president in more than four
decades last week.
And since 2003, African diamonds have been labeled and tracked, given
"birth certificates" in a process that tracks gems from extraction to
sale to ensure gems in Western jewelry stores don't fund rebels.
Yet in practice, rights groups say the oversight organization, called the Kimberley
Process, has had a number of problems that could keep it from being
effective if conflict were to break out again in major diamond producers.
And residents in some of the diamond-producing nations recovering from years
of war say they still aren't seeing much benefit from the gems leaving their
shores for markets in North America or Europe.
Sierra Leone's eastern diamond region still has poor roads and little
electricity or running water.
Partnership Africa Canada, a Canadian pressure group, says most miners in
Sierra Leone are not paid a salary, but are provided with food and mining tools
by the holder of a mining license, then forced to sell their finds back to the
license holder at below-market prices.
In major diamond producer Botswana, the Basarwa, popularly known as Bushmen,
have accused the government of trying to force them from their ancestral
homelands to make way for mining diamonds and other minerals. The government has
denied the charges. A judge was to rule on a case filed by the Basarwa later
this month.
Such issues are outside the purview of the Kimberley Process, a voluntary
71-nation group created out of the uproar about diamond-funded wars in Sierra
Leone and Angola.
The group, whose members agree only to buy or sell certified diamonds, has
helped conflict diamonds drop to less than 1 percent of the world's diamonds,
from about 4 percent previously.
"We are striving to make it zero," said Eli Izhakoff, chairman of
the industry World Diamond Council. "We want to tighten up more of the
controls."
Global Witness, one of the groups that started the campaign against conflict
diamonds back in 1998, said Kimberley is weak and too quick to trust the word of
member governments.
"At this point, should armed conflict spark up again in some of the
countries that were most affected ... we're not confident that the Kimberley
Process is yet strong enough to stem the flow of conflict diamonds," said
Annie Dunnebacke, a Global Witness campaigner.
Only a few countries are still considered sources of conflict diamonds. Ivory
Coast and Liberia are banned from exporting diamonds by UN resolutions. Liberia
-- which elected Africa's first female president nearly a year ago -- is hoping
to have the sanctions lifted soon. Ivory Coast is still struggling to hold
elections and UN sanctions aim to prevent rebels in the north of the war-divided
nation from profiting from the stones.
When Ivory Coast diamonds were found to be leaking over the border into Ghana
and sold by Ghanaians with Kimberley certificates earlier this year, the
information came not from one of the Kimberley Process's periodic reviews, but
from reports by activists and a UN review commission.
A report released in September by the US General Accounting Office found that
the US systems for controlling diamond imports and exports were "vulnerable
to illicit trade." The report said while diamonds arrived at ports with
Kimberley Process certificates, officials did not periodically inspect the
shipments to see that the contents matched the paperwork.
Over the years, rights groups say the Kimberley Process has seldom been the
initiator of disciplinary action. But Izhakoff said credit should be given for
the action that has been taken.
Even its critics acknowledge that the problems are minor in a generally
successful program that has started to bring order to a previously unregulated
industry. The group kicked out the DRC in 2004 because it couldn't account for
exporting significantly more diamonds than it mined. And at a yearly meeting
last month, the Kimberley Process told Ghana it had three months to clean up its
diamond industry.
Partnership Africa Canada, which had been very critical of the Kimberley
Process, said in a report last month that the group was taking the right steps
toward reform and commended the World Diamond Council's request for government
oversight of the industry as "a first in the annals of government-industry
regulatory discourse."
With greater regulation, legal diamond exports have risen in most of the
affected countries, bringing greater revenue to governments through taxation and
partnerships.
Yet, there are countries that belong to the Kimberley
Process whose governments are still aspiring to control the vast industry --
some with large untapped re-sources. In addition, only a small proportion of the
diamonds mined in Africa are processed on the continent, meaning the skilled
jobs and much of the earnings are elsewhere.
read also
diamond facts
Diamond Economic impact fact.
Generating Revenues from conflict free diamonds
The global
diamond industry employs some 10 million people directly and indirectly
all over the world, including Africa. The vast majority of the world's
diamonds come from sources that use the revenues generated by diamonds
to aid their national development. Given good governance and appropriate
laws, diamonds are a vital source of revenue for building infrastructure
and essential social services such as hospitals and schools. read diamond
facts