Hoge Raad Diamant HRD: Whose Voice Will Be Heard and Who's in Charge?
The motto of Belgium might be ‘L'union Fait la Force’, meaning strength
lies in unity, but theses days Antwerp seems anything but united, and it's
harming its strength. Battles in and around the city’s diamond umbrella
organization, the Hoge Raad voor Diamant (HRD),
reached a pinnacle last week.
(January 19, '06, 16:31 Edahn Golan found at http://www.idexonline.com/
)
After a long round of discussions with various Antwerp insiders, it is difficult
to pinpoint exactly what the argument is about. But last week it reached a new
peak, when Dilip Mehta quit the HRD board of directors, following the
resignation of CEO Peter Meeus, and followed by four political figures
representing the public and the channel through which the industry speaks to the
government,.
Rosy Blue CEO Dilip Mehta and a major Diamond Trading Company (DTC) Sightholder,
announced he was resigning from the board, saying he could not recognize himself
anymore in the HRD, adding that “large players are apparently not welcome
anymore.”
According to Mehta, the polished diamond traders association BVGD has been very
aggressive in its actions. BVGD filed various legal complaints against the DTC
and even against the HRD over Mehta’s board appointment.
With strong rumors about wrong doings at the HRD (all denied by the supposed
allegers or accused when asked to comment) that sent emotions high, and
continued ill communications that are preventing the HRD from carrying out some
of its activities – the annual Antwerp Conference didn’t take place in 2005
– the departures of Meeus and Mehta were followed by that of another
Sightholder, Chaim Pluczenik who also left the board. This string of
resignations was followed by those of public officials on the board: the
Governor of the Province of Antwerp, Camille Paulus; Antwerp’s mayor Patrick
Janssens; alderman for diamonds, Leo Delwaide; and former Flanders Prime
Minister Luc Van Den Brande. They reportedly resigned out of disenchantment with
the organization.
An outcome of the new situation in the market, Sightholders did not bring their
goods to the Diamond Office this week. On the one hand, this is not an official
requirement, since the goods came from within the European Union, from London,
but it is a custom remaining from pre-EU days. On the other, however, it’s
more then mere symbolism: the HRD collects a small fee when diamonds pass
through the office, a fraction of the value of the diamonds, which generates
millions of euros annually, that will not enter its coffers.
In a further sign of the HRD's lost footing, Mehta is now suggesting the
formation of a parallel organization. “We are socially responsible people,”
he says, offering to form a separate association where he and like minded
diamond traders could “decide on our own destiny.”
According to the opposition voices, the big companies have a separate agenda to
promote and as a result the small and medium size companies have different needs
that are not being addressed.
“The crucial task is that there is a delicate balance to be found between the
large Sightholders and the small and middle players to keep a healthy market
going,” says the BVGD in a release.
“The next Director-General of HRD will have to find that delicate balance:
satisfy the needs of the large players and at the same time firmly prevent their
desire to eliminate other players as demanded by their ‘Supplier of Choice.’”
But despite these reasonable sounding words, the Handel Group, which
incorporates the BVGD, the rough traders, the industrial diamond traders, and
the color gems traders, have succeeded in angering many in the industry.
Daniel van Dievoet, who is in many ways the face of the Handel Group, will
probably be a leading candidate for the vice president post at the HRD elections
next week. He opposed the HRD plan to open a grading lab in Mumbai, claiming
that it would take business away from Antwerp.
Resigning HRD managing director Meeus express irritation over efforts to prevent
him from implementing a large scale marketing effort to promote Antwerp as a
brand and to strengthen its position in the global market. “I challenge anyone
to come up with a better plan for Antwerp,” he says.
The underlying reason for Meeus' resignation is the thwarted international
marketing campaign, for which he blames van Dievoet. Marketing the HRD
certification, he says, would have helped the small and medium size companies.
With lab created diamonds and consumers' increased knowledge, Antwerp sourced
diamonds are highly regarded in the world; an advantage Meeus wanted to
capitalize on.
Frustrated by his inability to do the work, even though the plan that included
NYC and Mumbai offices was approved twice by the HRD, at his last board meeting
Meeus declared, “I do not want to be the captain of a sinking ship.”
This brings us back to Mehta and his plan for HRD ‘B’ and the new vision for
Antwerp. Is this the right solution? Getting away from what one called in
disgust “dwarfs” and forming a parallel organization to Antwerp’s diamond
umbrella organization?
Even clear supporters of Mehta fear such a drastic move. One of the main jobs
Mehta is planning for the proposed new entity will include what he calls “proper
legislation”, which means talking with the government. He does not want to
create new research or grading labs. This echoes what Meeus calls ‘the
important question’: “Where is the vision?”
While one HRD insider said that the big guys don’t really need the HRD, “they
have branding, and don’t need an Antwerp brand,” a board member said the
solution to Antwerp’s problems could meet some relief if the city is declared
a tax free trade zone. This could resolve some burning financial issues that
current legislation does not address.
This is a hushed and explosive topic that no one wants to talk about directly.
Nonetheless, how the center resolves its bad habits from yesteryear is currently
on the operating table, with hopes that the operation succeeds and the
proverbial patient lives.
related: Antwerp World Diamond
Centre
Diamonds
continue to sparkle despite all the global gloom | diamond
traders | houston diamond exchange
| World Diamond Council | Diamonds
news on Facebook ( thanks for the Like ) | Antwerp
diamonds history
